免费文献传递   相关文献

Thought on several problems of post-marketing herbs clinical evaluation in special populations

中药上市后特殊人群有效性及安全性评价的若干思考



全 文 :rÇ_S¾¯°±Gèé›GEO›
9:[HIJ‘
4o
#
Cpq
!
!
9<9IJ¯K ˎÌIK
#
´µ
PMMMLO
$
ž;
%!
ò­rÇ]_S¾
!
…ǯ°±G͛[è‰bé
#
EO›[j‰()

EF±™`ArÇ_S¾¯°±
Gj‰ƒ„RÉJ‘
!
RrÇh.Ɖ¯°±G[›ÇÀ½Òe
&
EO›9:ƒ„…”è7«9:
#
()‡ˆ
#
?@ƒ
„
#
ÇÌW%
!
ì…Ç«„›
#
x•›
&
èé›9:jAڎ
!
&¯©‰?ö÷
#
ê÷±
#
øù
#
´µ•ù¹
#
z{Þg|DFÄ¥
͛rÚÇ

$
Ÿ ¡
%!
¯°±G
&

&
_S¾Ö9:
&
èé›
&
EO›
$
8$f
%!WMPPMNMXMPM
$
‘’Ep
%!
­æ
)
i¬ŠÇBÜ
*
ö÷i¬«u
$WMM_e+M_LMW;
MOM%
$
“Ž>”
%!
!
n§¨
!
ƒ„°
!
?@
!
ƒ„…†êrUÇ?@9:
!
@(&.$MPM%NNMMP^MW!-;I$&.&6ILXL\0/#4fG/I
$
>”š›
%!
ò©
!
Á@ƒ„ã
!
ƒ„…†ê~6ª$iGª>¥
[ua
!@(&.PO^MPMNLPO[!-;I$&.D/&(2`#/4\PO_FG/I
!!
՝U]§¥[ÈÃ
!
]rÇ_Sh[á™?@ç¨
r
!
ö÷
#
ê÷±
#
²³•G´µ•ù¹‡¯°±G
!
™Ñ¨
ä]®

ÃÍ
!
]rÇ_S¾
!
…Ç]¼c¯°±Gr͛
[è‰bé
#
EO›[j‰()

ϝã¥ÈÃ
!
rÇ]¼
c¯°±G[ô­¡i¬™Ú÷±*gäè|Ô[CE
!
Çé
#
Ç·‡*gè²D
|«Í›Y¬
!
Yìw/A

!
òÝäHD»pF[¶£

”÷;
!
­~ƒ„F—˜
‰?_S¾rÇ]¯°±G[èé›GEO›9:
!
ÏRÉ
´Ø6j‰ƒ„

¤7±rÇh.ÆÀ½Rë
#
ƒ„…”
#
QÇ<
#
·é‰F
#
²³EO›Ç‡…TRÉF†

!
rÇh.Ær¯°±G͛[À½Rë

P(
‡A§ƒ®UVRÉ͛[
WN
 rÇ?SÛ[
h.ÆRÉã.
!
R],ê÷±›Çƒ„
#
,øù´µ•
ù¹›Çƒ„
#
,ö÷›Çƒ„[ ¨6©ê
_WfNXg!
N_fW_g!NLf[Pg
+.²
W(
‡A
OM
¯rÇ?SÛ[ǟ
h.ÆRÉã.
!
ö÷›Ç
#
ê÷›Ç¼
W
uÀ½Pê°

øùG´µ•ù¹›ÇÀ½Pê
Xf[g!
6©ê
)
ÞY./
*
Ñ
)
øù¬›
*
Z7
L
¯h.Æ]
)
?@×u
*
À½øù¬
›J^›
!^
¯h.Æ]
)
?@×u
*
À½ê÷±¬›


lj
)
ö÷›·Æ±J²ÉÆ·
*
[§1\›!û
!
]h.
Ær>,./À½
!
fê÷±Gøù´µ•ù¹[›Ç!û
Î…Ç

*#rÇh.ÆrAê±
#
ö÷
#
øù
#
´µ•
ù¹‡¯°±G[›ÇÀ½Òe

ϝ¯°±Gꫯ[Ø8³´J¾89\þY
!
A
ÇÌ[š\¥`äè²CE
!
h.Ær[
)
‚a
*
>YOg
µ¶tÇ[ab2ÿ

Xû·y h.Ær
!
Þg‚aêó
xŒ-
#
SŽS¬
!
›ÝOy
#
¸¹þy
#
\³›¬$‡
!
>ßµGžßài

ìÎ
!
?@›ab6öžßàiYê

O(
!
¾Ë²ãØÃ+
!
]6öžßài÷Ñ!ýrµG·
y *›6öžßài[ab
!
­W\t¦)j‰”Ó
!
’“ÓԏeÏ16öabžßài[j‰™Â
!
(ªh


#
rÇ_S¾¯°±GEO›Gèé›9:[J‘
rÇ_S¾\Uҗ±•?@
!
•?@[|l
<Î&A¯°±GRɃ„

û•¾DÛ·
#
¾DÛǽ
¾
#
òaö÷›Ç‡
!
\¦)”ÓÏ1­æhŸÇŸWi
¥2
$1JR=%
Ã+¾…*RɃ„

rÇ_S¾¯°±GEO›9:ƒ„…”è7«9:
#
()‡ˆ
#
?@ƒ„
#
ÇÌW%

º»6‹ÎvhÇÌEO
›9:r͛À™[ƒ„…”
!
ªÎïњĴ¬·ƒ„0
•

?@ƒ„rӏT–CÎvhƒ„¯°±GY“”[ã¼P[i&…”

ÔJƒ„r[hh›ƒ„i²ƒ
„[Y“×qÎZl[

vh
!
¯°±GEO›ƒ„Ye
!
n[;¬‚&ÎÏ
UãH®?@_’“rÚÇh.Æ͛[Û·
#
͛±G
#
Y“”\1a
#
sl1ù[Y“×q1ù¼
#
^qG?
@×uRÉÎ6‹²&
!
*êF@Š[š\i¥G
EO[¯°±GÇ·
!
ꗱhh›[¯°±GEO›ƒ„
µo‘DÅ

éf
!
ò­Þæè6A›[
#
èÐ
#
x•[¯
°±GEO›9:
!
ûq¯°±GrÚÇEO›ƒ„wè2
#›GBd›
!
šï”ÉK¯°±GrŒ][›ÇEO›†
p

ò­ÇÌWÜÜÁ³lY½
!
>érÇمGÚ6
wèj£›
!
rÇ[?@稃„֝FO–—
!
•?@
/X[[W/
{
OX
ï{
WM
•
WMPP
÷
PM
²
!!!!!! ! ! ! ! ! !!!! ! ! ! !
S/&fOX! :004(!WM
TG2/b(%! WMPP
ç¨ÞY(
!
¯°±G͛rÚÇEO›ƒ„s¤Îc
t

\Ï­W·Ä?@ƒ„;1U҂ʗ±Yêڎ[
¯°±GEO›ƒ„

rÇ_S¾¯°±Gèé›9:ƒ„…”è¾£›ƒ
„
#
6‹›ƒ„
#
稛ƒ„

ï°±GpF]RÉç¨
›ƒ„7
!
Î]èé?@abêv[hµª§¸
!
ÛDž
ú*]?@Ç¥UAi¤«W?@UA[3ØÄEªRÉ
[›ÏíèéÇêқA“[\;ç¨

pÓ\;lMA
“ç¨
!
¼¨á.…”¼*uS´µ›Bd
#
%·›Bd
!
å
*uS£Ã—[Ÿ 


!
£è\;Êùç¨
#
h
;
¾A
“ç¨
#
-\;A“稇

ÔJƒ„]abû›i…TÏ
w訤Gþ4&
#
*x•\ÿ
#
¿Îua°¸[™¨
\‡é}
!
ÃÍ]…”]\›rŒ]{¬„N
!
AÆU][
Æ)‡ºê#º
^(

¯°±Gè雃„YEO›ƒ„fž
!
Ï|Ú|j
Aڎ[þF
!
ò­‰ö÷
#
ê÷±rÚÇèé›?@ƒ
„ÏèYe
!

.)
ó߀abê÷Lßë[?@º
»
*
L(
#)
lmn€ab6ö_‡GaPQb麻
*
X(

稛ƒ„Îvh͛À™[è雃„…”

ìÎ
!
vh
rÇ_S¾¯°±Gèé›9:…Çx•ƒ„
!
‰ê÷±
x?›ÇA²pªÑ$i[Ÿ 
!
²³•ù¹›ÇAÀö]
ö÷•[ãx“Ÿ æèj\[9©

$
¯°±G[ƒ„è‘&RÉQÇ]¯°±G[ƒ„r
!
Î]?@èé[hµª§¸
!
Û
Džú*]?@Ç¥UAi¤«W?@UA[3ØÄEª

!
ä´º»¥ë
#
þÐ
#
|Ÿã\!À
$
z
#
{Þg‡
%
G
ïC®
!
£\3؉?QDZfAípF[EO
›

´µ•ù¹aç¨7
!
DªÍ›®›abµ¤$iÇ
Ì
!
ab•šªŠãöÀ|Y&#~µÁK
!
ÓLÎ͛à
žJ?SÇÌ
!
å\¬i
!
Z7\7ÂW%µÃ~ÇÌ<

%
9:ö÷\‘º·é‰FGãx“É´
,
rÚÇ?@\›!ûȜ
-
r!K
.
ö÷›Ç|ŸÉ´
O
ŏ~ž
P Z^
Ú±·
!O hL
Å[*ž
PZO
Ú±·
!L hPM
Å
[*ž
PZW
Ú±·
!PM
ŏ_iÚ±·jCY¬Ó*

šé
vhö÷rÚÇ?@ƒ„r
!
ÛǑº´Í‡É´
!
ì>æ
è6‹50YZ÷»—ÀX³éÛ·GabÛ·
!
žÇÛ·
.P…”YÝ9/
!
]ÇÌbé9:r
!
*±À6Û·—˜
ðñòaÄ
!
á.F†·é‰F[ƒ„…ú

vhh.Ær>æèÄ¥[ö÷›·h.
!
]RÉö÷
EO››Çƒ„r
!
ÛÇÛ·*²É¾D
!
’ÄÛÇ
!
\2
ÅNO›ÇÛ·
!
þ\ÛÇÇÌÛ·

ö÷•\3ØW–
ªãx“É´
!
º»¿àÅ[D$
ûÆǂË
#
æ+[
“D\‡
%!
W%þi
#
áÁ
#
`ÿ
#
qÿ
#
ÈÉGÊË“
É´

&
¯°±GÖ9:\#i
#
›ÇêØ
›F]͛‚D
)
ê÷±
*
Ñ
)
rÚÇ
*#)
ö÷
*
Ñ
)

Ç
*
]
>C:
rbOR
!
‰ê÷±[¼¨ƒ„™Ì†
ÁQM
#
{ßi
!
fö÷œÌ†®P$i
!
0Ä_£0•
!
vhƒ„R돺”É´|-
.
A¯°±GRÉ_S¾rÇ
èé›9:
!
\Z»Gþ|¨
!
éØ´µ]?@r6ÈÍ
›[
#
bé/Ø[
#
Ö9:×g‡[rÚÇEê9:Aô

]abi [´µ_\#i
#
i¬$i
#
¬ÓkŽÉi
êÖ9:i-
!
Œ¼­æÑÈäT?[–вãwD
!
Í
Ö9:)»þR§1[\›:_
[(


ƒ„…ú
)
i
*#)
Æ
*#)
¥
*

vh¯G¯°±G[è雃„r
!
Œê§ÇÌab§
$iƒ„
!
ìÎrÇϝlá¯{
!
‘„¦Æ,a
!
‘é?@
ƒ„YgO“Í)ǃ„k}

t¨±GJêÎÏßÞ
#
|Oßágþ
!
JênÎñ%‡‡
!
þYŒi±YZ
!
ª¦
ƅT`äècKÐ
!
ûHòaƤ6Ù
!
\qF†rÇ]
§ $i§|¯Ô±G[šgƤ
!
YçVh.Ær‚a
#
Þé&(6
!
`è¬Ä¥Q!û?@›Ç

(
(rÚDz³EO‡ºÜ
ò­>æèÜÔrÚÇA²³•ù¹GÀöŸ [6º
Ü
!
qvh²³•ù¹rÚǃ„>Y6È

(rÚ
Dz³EO‡ºÜÎΪgg

]Rɲ³•ù¹EO›
ƒ„7
!
¶*g´µAÀöGøù,H|[ÇÌ
!
fwè.u
qp›[ÇÌ\^›
&
fê)ƒ„v[×&
!
]øùãBÐH
J$i2if,”\›YEO[ÇÌJÇÌ,é7
!
×c¶
AÀöèH|›
!
AøùÌÔªè¬[ÇÌ*´µƒ„

‘º»²³h
O
²›ÇAÀöqpPYÁ
!
²³Y»
O
²[
pF¶·YïÐ
!
H¿çv[
$
ûAÀ
%
‚&6At¨±G*
²ÉïÐ
!
ì‘ç2ÅW}ãBþÐ
#
Àß
#
Àʇ

²³•
ù¹\º»øùQM
#
ÀÊ
#
Àß
#
Ñ8·
#
ŠãöþiG9
6
#
²³>¥
#
Žä
#
Àöҝ
#
íÀÑÀöp|
!
>\]ä
¾\ÿ
!
·ö[ãx“ÏÎQö÷A¶Øüï%þi
#
á
Á
#
`ÿÑqÿ
!
>i»6ÓÙ·ö[“!(XY

)
?ix•é!
‰?ê÷±·Ä›Ç
Y“”\r‰ö÷
#
Dì”\FI™
!
ê÷±Ye
!
>
YÎh.ê÷±Y4ãY“”!
f΅ÇAê÷±x•
͛™ ÇÌEO›9:º»

²³•pF›Çr
!
AÀÇ
Ì[EO›9:e
!
é…Ç侶ö[x•Ô?\ÿ
!
Yg
º9:rÚÇAÀö[Y“Ÿ 
&
´µ•pF[EO›9
:Z¨ûÍ

£ÕÖ
N(
‡A6S
_^^
Mê÷±›Ç–Cr
!NWf^g
ê÷±pè
P
 J( û›$i
!
 Œ7±p
PfX_
 û›
$i

]іC[
_^^
Mê÷±r
![Xf_g
[±x•žÇ
!
À™FZ7ž›
[
 
!
 Œ7±ž›
PfNN
 

ê÷±Ãã
¥ÞgÆÊûqÇÌ]þ~ô­Æ¼
!
fpè$i ¨ê™
GÇÌ·Ä͛ê™
!
ªY“”\äã[ÃPê¬

]E
O›9:r
!
\iæßÚQ
#
z{Þg[D!
À|wþ
»¿FãD\É´G²p$i[±D!
\ÿ÷#êx
/[[[W/
{
OX
ï{
WM
•
WMPP
÷
PM
²
!!!!!! ! ! ! ! ! !!!! ! ! ! !
S/&fOX! :004(!WM
TG2/b(%! WMPP
ê|

]èé›9:r
!
ϝê÷±[[p虠û›$i
!
]6‹_S¾ÇÌab§$ij‰‚&!ÀD\[Z7
!
£
\?@j‰$i[¾(É´

è[ê÷±[[Ä>ªÑ›
Ç
!
ƒ„¼.
!
͛¼PIh
L
I[Ç̦5Îß
#
ÚQ›
Ç
#
×li›Ç
#
Õ]Ê˛Ç
#
‡GFã›Ç
#
oa›
Ç
N(

Í7`\‘»·Ä›ÇA²p¿ û›i[Ÿ 
!

Gr)Ç·Ä͛[jxj”›

*
A–¿çF¬ë
ϝö÷](í_Ñl}›.uèEÚ±
!
ÇÌ[{
ÇG7PAªžÇ¦±›è.uŸ 

]—±Aö÷RÉ
[rÇèé›9:7
!
|Ô&á6‘º¼-
!
À¬#QÆ
erÇGÛ{7Ï;[Y“Ÿ 

,
±þãÌU]ƒ„­1§¥!ý
-
!K
.
]ö÷“Ñ
ØN¿Î2ÿ~ùíªç¨É´¾
!
\Ðö÷[ÄE
@¿

ÓÍèÙ~[Î*
!
ö÷V@”Aaƒ„\,P®
Q&»Úi
!
ä-ö÷×&[ab]ƒ„®[¦qªYg
Â&
!
ƒ„I‰°¸‰½èabé•
!
>éæè;±Þ@[
¾ôb”

]¼ É´ª
!
û•Ûf÷»Y¬>éàg
ÝÛ=«„[íÉZ@
!
ƒ„F\@ö]ѧ¥BC×°
ä[¯©Ã+JÎ*8*—˜J‚˜ƒ„›ab
_(


!
EF]͛
)
rÚÇ
*
Ñ
)
²³
*Z)
´µ•
*
ïO7
R
!
²³•
Z
´µ•ù¹Í›rÚÇ>Y™

ì>Ygh
.ù¹]ͯ°7•Í›rÇYe
!
fΉ¼–—ù¹Í
›rÇlЅ
#
lÜÛ[7«>Ye
!
ûÜÀ’aƅ?@
èé›
WX
Ý

šéÍY¯G_S¾rÇ9:ƒ„
!
ìê´
pFEO›
!
‡ÞUÇL\‰?²³•
Z
´µ•pF͛r
ÇǟY·
#
ÇéGEO›9:

¶‰¯°±G[rÚǃ„³lY½
!
ìò­A¯
°±G͛_S¾rÇèé›Ï|Ú´|ƒ„…”þF
!
>é\]­æ”ӝ(
!
öƒ8 [±
!
n\ʎò
!
ö÷›ÇÛ·Gê÷±™ ›ÇŸ äðñaÐèé›9
:r
!
Vè¬h.ƽ»
!
±f»/!û?@›Ç

ì
ϝvhrÇEO›öƒþFYڎ
!
á.YÝá6
!
q
¯°±GEO›Í›rÚÇ[ƒ„~G…”wè2#›

jn¶Oj\[”ÓÜG¨ß
JR=
[rÚDz³›Ç6
¨
!
—±C?
#
èÐ[ƒ„
!
6A¿¨¯°±G[¯-RÉj
\[…úá.
!
VäµÁͨpFrÚÇEO›ƒ„8 
!
|Q½»G‚áh.Æ
!
!ûpF»/›Ç

$
œ‡ˆ
%
P(!

!
²àà
!
¦²ú
f
m¡ÇŸh.ÆáærÇ?SÛ[E

9(f
r­Ç×
!WMPM!W^$X%.LL_f
W(!
+.²
!
⨤
!
ã`Š
!
‡
f
rÇ?SÛh.ÆY“”\j‰
uv¼£É´[–Cƒ„
9(f
?@Ä¥›Ç£¤
!WMPM!O
$PL%.PP^f
O(!
îä©
f
·y abö÷žßài[?@bé9:
9(f

UV
!WMMN!N$X%.LPf
^(!
+åÎ
!
þæ
!
£D 
f
ÔJƒ„i\;A“ç¨[…”]X
Y
9(f
øùrUǬ]]1
.
rU?@Â
!WMMN!PL$L%.PPf
L(!
£2ç
!

f
ó߀abê÷Lßë[?@º»
9(F
r)U0ÄßÚQi£¤
!WMM_![$N%.N_Nf
X(!
Dóè
!
ºé
f
lmn€ab6ö_‡GaPQb麻
9(f
Rôr)U0Ä£¤
!WMPP!W$P[%.LMf
[(!
âê
!
­®¯
!
)+y
f
rÇ_S¾?@Ö9:ƒ„HID

9(f
r­rÇ£¤
!WMPM!OL$PW%.PX^Pf
N(!
£ÕÖ
!
ë­ì
!
­æí
!
‡
f_^^
Pê÷±›ÇÉ´–C6‹
9(f
+¥Ç]
!WMM_!P_$[% .^Wf
_(!
îïð
!
ñìì
f
?@ç¨r¯°¿ç±G´µ[­1§¥&

9(f
r­?@Ç¥]iab]
!WMMO!N$O%.OLXf
?EBIWEDBCKASAG/1OGBM1A.KBNOBKD-./GVAD0CW EAGMKL10C0L/1AS/1I/D0BC
0CKOAL0/1OBOI1/D0BCK
e.T,=! B:=>J()*I(
!
$D&+#9E+#5# =($>%!+1! 0/%#+ 4,+356()0/%#$23%,+17,%#,$! *%8%#9 PMMMLO! 0/%#+%
6MKDG/LD( @#(%(;(D$&4$2/) /6G&)G$&U/02;I$%V(2)*#(%b0) 0U(G$&U/U4&$2/)0! 04G# $0G#&5%()! 2#($*(5! U%(*)$)2
E/I()! &$G2$2)*E/I()! #$0$2%$G2(5 $2()2/) ) /4%G/4)2%AF@#(I(5$05%4*$5D(%0(%($G2/) %(U/%20$)5 U$GV$*()0(%2F@#(
0$6(2A/6G/Ib)(5 $5I)02%$2/) ) $*(5 $)5 G#&5%()n0*%/E2# 0#/4&5 #$D(b(() 2$V() &/)*;2(%I6/&/E;4U 0245AF8(%6(G2)*2%$52/)$&
G#)(0(I(5G)(JR=0A02(IE&b(b()(6G$&2/2#(%(;(D$&4$2/) /6G&)G$&U/02I$%V(2)*#(%b0) U%(*)$)2E/I()FR/0(;(6(G2
0245A) G#&5%() $&0/0#/4&5 G$40(2#(G/)G(%) /6%(0($%G#(%0F
[AF XBGHK(!0U(G$&U/U4&$2/)0& #)(0(I(5G)(& U/02;I$%V(2)*%(;(D$&4$2/)& 0$6(2A& (6(G2D()(00
HB0.!+c%#)RLYL..#+!!#++%
$
•–$Q
!
—˜™
%
/N[[W/
{
OX
ï{
WM
•
WMPP
÷
PM
²
!!!!!! ! ! ! ! ! !!!! ! ! ! !
S/&fOX! :004(!WM
TG2/b(%! WMPP