免费文献传递   相关文献

Analysis of several key problems of good agricultural practice (GAP) of Chinese materia medica

中药材规范化种植(GAP)几个关键问题商榷



全 文 :2016
y

z ³
41
ų

}
Vol41,No.7 April,2016

”•)(
] 20160301

–—˜R
] 
ì(81130070);
ìhlmnopjk
(2012BAI29B02,2012BAI28B002)

™x?š
] 
567
,Tel:(010)64014411,Email:huangluqi01@126com
·
WX
·
$,Š‹Œ_Ž
(GAP)
‘’“Q”
-.

/01

234

567


!!#h%q !$rs!t uC$vìwxyz{|iC

}~
100700)

›
] 
|^–—D$,Š
GAP
㱝°ÉÊ

—àD


P(GMP,GLP,GSP,GCP,GAP)
m×±ƒ

‚ž´Ssì
$,Š
GAP
ÖnD—à

‰d$,Š
GAP
µä’“±SÉ£F´‹š

X±$,Š
GAP
ɸ¹ôŠ
,GAP
DÃr
_–Þßv<¿ã¤4ù$W¶

6·ür¿¸¹4ùºä
GAP
Ñv
GAP
,Š±J`

jQéˆ
GAP
ôŠ±¶ñ

|^
#dD‚¿´±‰]@

.¥»x
GAP
±ôŠË¾

ʳLœôŠf÷“¼ôŠ


GAP
â핽ÞÂÈ

,×17±
¾(¦íM1Fä׿¬3S³LœôŠf÷

#dØÙ
GAP
ôŠ±v
ç±
GAP
Ñ4ù±zÀ


œž
] GAP;
Ë>´

$,Ë>

Ë>3S

³LœôŠ
Analysisofseveralkeyproblemsofgoodagricultural
practice(GAP)ofChinesemateriamedica
YANGGuang,GUOLanping,ZHOUXiuteng,HUANGLuqi
(StateKeyLaboratoryBreedingBaseofDaodiHerbs,NationalResourceCenterforChineseMateriaMedica,
ChinaAcademyofChineseMedicalSciences,Beijing100700,China)
[Abstract] ThispaperreviewedthehistoricalbackgroundoftheGAP,analyzedthedevelopmentexperienceoffivePs(GMP,GLP,
GSP,GCP,GAP),analyzedtheGAPbasedoneconomictheories,andpointedoutthatthecoreproblemofGAPisignoringeconomic
lawsOncetheGAP,isaprocessofcertification,butneithertheGAPannouncementcouldbetransformedintosignaltransmission
qualityintheproductmarket,norconsumerscouldrecognizethediferencebetweenGAPandnonGAPherbsintheterminalmarket,
somanufacturerslackmotivationforGAPcertificationInthispaper,wepointedout,thattheGAPcertificationsystemshouldberede
signedundertheguidanceofeconomics,thirdpartycertificationbody,supervisedbydrugadministrationorganization,tocertificate
GAPashighqualitystandards,toimprovesignaltransductionmechanismofGAPcertification,andtointegrateGAPwiththemarket
[Keywords] GoodAgriculturePractice;resourceeconomics;traditionalChinesemedicinalresources;resourceadministration;
thirdpartycertification
doi:10.4268/cjcmm20160702
  GAP
É$,ŠÂãÞß3S‹Œ
“GoodAgriculture
Practice”
±Á¼

»%•
2003
yIìm‹çm

$,ŠÂã
Þß3S‹ŒôŠ3S

n
)》(
%ò,×8
[2003]
251
<
)。
¿
GAP
ôŠn±
13


»%$,Š‹Œ_Â
ãÖ
w%Äx
196
‘$,Š1Fç±D
GAP
Ž

í•dŒÅ)¬åÆÃÂãÅ)†L¶©H
GAP
/‡ÖnŽ
,GAP
Ž±SYîÇO$S
,GAP
ôŠ{
dŠ$,Š±Þ߬8w

}ÐÑ»%4ù´L°Fí±î

4ùÑÈɗg
ŽÅúî

•DÁÈ;‰

/—Ï;4ùðñ

%R>hm

ŸÖ6
13
¿%R>17nÈíM(¿±8â
》(
%m
〔2016〕10
<
),
‹âÖ6$,ŠÂãÞß3S‹Œ
(GAP)
ô
·3711·
2016
y

z ³
41
ų

}
Vol41,No.7 April,2016
Š
。GAP
ôŠÖ6Íán)²¯

%N’“Z–•«+S
±«ë

9^¿–—Ñuœ
GAP
mם¹±1i÷


´Ssì
GAP
±%N’“ÖnD—à

•SµÊ¦
GAP
mג“#GÊN¬Ë<

1 GAP
±±²Ê–Ã
11 GAP
çm±ÉÊ
Ì4,Š±LG_]c
GAP
ß¿Ln

»%±$
,ŠÏ>XaúÂ,Š•L

Ì4¤„ê

Ž¥
–‹P

ÐÑ$,g)±Íá

Ë>6ΜómÂo
 

í•úÂ,Šî¥{ÏÐ:‡

Ì4,Šñ.ÑÍ
ֆ

¿
1995
yO»%$,ŠŽ‘2OöÐ0˜‘

019%,
ä
2014
y’[ñ¨î÷Üä
12%,
$
,ŠŽ‘2îÕ¸
198536khm2(
¥ëø@Ž¬
úÂÒÓ
),
îÕ¸Ô

£Ì
[1]。
›f‹Œ$,Š±
Ž¸¹

­®Ž¥”ÍáÞߒ“•ï:7
8±’“

q
1)。
q
1 
$,ŠŽ‘2öÐ0˜±ñ¨
Fig1 Percentageofsownareasofmedicinalmaterials
12 
$,Š
GAP
Ss«¬
uœ$,Š
GAP
±Ss«¬^”

³[Äɱ²—
à

›!3Õì
GAP
1F±²±^”—à
[2],
DÖH
òÅƱ×ØD
GAP
±d0

ÉÊ

š·>

198ê

ôŠ¬Ùk/ëè8ê
[3];
³€ÄÉ4Ú
GAP
çm¸¹
$±Ss’“

›yEÛ
GAP
ôŠY±ieÊ4ùIÜ
’“
[4],
!lª«¬ºÂP›ã˜Ñ
GAP
±Å’
“
[5];
³LÄÉ¥œ¿
GAP
¸¹$±‚ž

›ÀÝÞ
è4ÚÂß±rS¿
GAP
±‚ž
[6],
Dàm4Úvâ
()¿
GAP
±‚ž
[7],
Qáxèì
GAP
,Šm×#dD
ò•Åƀ¯
[8]。
13 
$,Š
GAP
ç⫬
GAP
ç⫬È$¿U,Š‹Œ_Ž±‹¹pç
mÒJ÷

›Lý
[9]、
ãSä
[10]、

[11]、
ÜÝ
[12]
è,Š±
‹Œ_Ž‹¹

ÙÚ

…W

¢èÒJ÷

>¥ØwÆx

¸‹Œ_Ž«¬±$,Š¿
100
åæ

…çwžÌ4
¤uèé¿8

ïÄ«¬ì‹Œ|$,Š±Ž¸¹
B2d0

14 GAP
1F±§¨µ–Ã
¦,×o±DÃϽ

»%
GAP
çm
13
yÏÄxD‹
196

GAP
1F

RS
126
‘Å)¬
70
,Š¤

ì$
A,n)§ê
,GAP
ôŠ±7Ód0Ž•úh

¦Žëä
Å)ä6·ü

‹Œ_Ž±SYîÇO$S

,Š:/
‹Œ_Ž’[ì“îî

}
GAP
,Š¿4ù÷bö
±ñ.¬¥…

a$ݕ¨

àÌ$ÝÉ
GAP
DÃíd±½
‡Qݱ,Š

}É>^”kÚîøïî@¸%‘
GAP
ô
Š±$ݍŽ‘2Oöw‘2±
2%,
¿,Š4ùç
„ºä
GAP
ôŠ±$Ý,Š
[13]。
2 
$,Š
GAP
çm$¿±’“—à
21 
ÑÓ⋌çmžŸ€ñ
GAP
Ö×yñ
GAP
É»%,¤×3°Å


P(GMP,GLP,GSP,GCP,
GAP)
$ð[‹HžŸ$,Š±ÞߋŒ
。GAP
3S°Å±
€»É



$òñ±[

çɏ¾Q…±[

Q6z
±*±É

$,ŠÂãÞß3S‹Œ

n
)》
•
2002

nD
12
y

Ÿò3bo?

§Óâ



óîo?¬¿
x•12eËçm

*
1)。
22 
ÑÐ)
GAP
€ñçÖ×yñ
Ñ$,Š
GAP
€Î±ÁBÕ÷Ð)‹Œ

Ð)
GAP)[14],
¿áͧ¨

$,Š
GAP
ÑÐ)
GAP
ۖ

$,
Š
GAP
ÁÉô¿DíK
[15],2006
y

z%‘ô×õm‹

Õ÷Ð)‹ŒôŠçm‹{

n
)》(CNCAN004:2006)
ñ$,Š
GAP
ñ

y

}Ð)
GAP
¿n

yY&ABo
?

§$,Š
GAP
Ÿò~¿n

ΏyÏÔ
GAP

õö

Ss«¬¬çâ–æö—jw

23 
$,Š
GAP
Ù÷lm¥»w
»%àÌòóçmáD$,
GAP
􊂙

}øì¸
b{€áد±$,Š
GAP
ôŠ°Å

aí±$,Š
GAP
ôŠ‹É¦‚™±¾¾ù¤$,ŠŽ¸¹±‹Œ_

éˆÙ÷±ÈElm

b{¶
GAP
Âã±,ŠÑ[ú,Š
J`IÏ

rç±
GAP
,Š±½Þ½

]c$,Š
GAP
rÑ4ùBÉìz
。GAP
‹{óÒ¿1Fû‘

]c
GAP
±ÂãG@IžüÏ

¥{@¸
GAP
ã¤ÖO$,Š4ù

GAP
ôŠ¥{¿ã¤ûº±_–v<6zCËD
GAP
¿$
,4ù÷±0ž

]cÅ)2µ¥Ý

í•
GAP
1F®
ç/

q
2)。
3 
$,Š
GAP
ôŠS’“Q”
31 
$,Š
GAP
ÂãÊ㤱âí
$,Š
GAP
ÑÐ)
GAP
âí¿Ø9ÔÕ

U¦ý‘
Ͻ
,“
Õ÷

dþÑÉ[\ÂÈ
,“
‹Œ_

{ÿBeË!n
±dÊ
。“
‹Œ_

Ñ

Õ÷

±Ô`ÖD,×17ÑÐ)
17쎘¤Þ3Sôõ±ÔÕ

U‹¦×3±¾¾#eË
ÂȎ&Ÿ!n

í^îg



$Óâ



uî¿x
•12eË!n


GAP
eË[nŽùV,¤×3±$µ
Êi

·4711·
P 


$,Š‹Œ_Ž
(GAP)
‘’“Q”
*
1 5


çmžŸñò
Table1 Progresscompareof5P(GMP,GLP,GSP,GCP,GAP)
®¼ ‹€» ƒuœ
GAP  2002
y

z

%‘ò¤,¤×¿3So
(SFDA)
m‹D

$,ŠÂãÞß3S‹Œ

n
)》,2003
y

z
16
{

%‘ò¤,¤×¿3Som‹D

$,ŠÂãÞß3S‹
ŒôŠ‚™~âÂÈ

n
)》
”m‹DÃ
22
º

n
12
y~bo?
GMP  1982
y

$%A,g)DEÝH[“QÖ%‘±,¤
GMP
ËBD

,¤Âã3S
‹Œ
》(
n%
),1988
y&Â1‹D»%³[P

,¤ÂãÞß3S‹Œ
》(GMP),
1992
&Â1AB¬‹çm

,¤ÂãÞß3S‹Œ
》。1994
y$%,¤ôŠõ3+
–

&Â1,¤ôŠ3S$S–
。1995
y

z&Â1m‹

ŸI×,¤
GMP
ô
Šg0±@
》;
,¤ôŠõ3+‹D

$%,¤ôŠõ3+ôŠ3S
》,SFDA
Ÿ
1999
y

z
18
{‹D¥±

,¤ÂãÞß3S‹Œ
》(1998
yAB
)1999
y

z

{ámn

&Â1
2011
ym‹

,¤ÂãÞß3S‹Œ
(2010
yAB
)》(
&Â1(³
79
<
),
•
2011
y

z

{ámn
 
1)Å)/—Ë<%ðQ֍ƒË ¿
Å)8n

*jƒ

L317ôM¬?ó‹ç
m

a+,œó[¶I×

–€‚±ôŠõ3+¬
ôŠ3S$S

úî$3¬f÷

L317AB3S


¦O¿ê=12[¶eËôŠ

-ê=12±
eËôŠ[Óäwn)

¬ÑÍ>â@Ï

L317
AB3S

#ÝôŠ7.

#ܯ°Þß
GCP  1998
y

z

&Â1‹D

,¤…†ƒ3S‹Œ
》(
n
);1999
y

z

{
SF
DA
?ó‹¬çm»%±

,¤…†ƒ3S‹Œ
》;
%‘ò¤,¤×¿3So.¥
ËâD

,˜…†ƒÞß3S‹Œ
》(GMP),
Ÿ
2003
y

z

{?ó‹çm

/
0
2014
y

z

”m‹
41
ºôâDÃ
 GCP
Ñ¥,±å1UVáÏ

NÖnx}…†
ƒ

$°Â˜nž¾p˜èɵƒu:©H
GCP
Ön

”m‹,˜…†ƒf÷ËèôâDÃ
41
º

36
º
SFDA
¬

º
CFDA
GLP  1999
y
10
z
14
{

%‘ò¤,¤×¿3So
(SFDA)
‹D

,¤v…†«¬Þß
3S‹Œ

n
)》(
Á¼
GLP),
¬Ÿ
1999
y
11
z

{ámn
。2003
y
SFDA
hm

,
˜v…†«¬Þß3S‹Œ‚™Â

n
)》(
%ò,×8
[2003]206
<
),2007
y

z
,SFDA
mD¥AB±

,˜v…†«¬Þß3S‹ŒôŠ3S
》,
/0
2014
y

z

”m‹
29
ºDÃ
(SFDA28

,CFDA1


 GLP
Ñ¥,±å1UVáÏ

¥,v…†8wµ~
«¬L2¿
GLP
烄Ön

”m‹DÃ
29


B
58
çƒ„@¸D
GLP
ôŠ
GSP  1992
y

z
18
{

%‘A,3Som‹D

A,Þß3S‹Œ
》(GSP1992
P
),
¬Ÿ
¦y
10
z

{áçn
。1993
y

z

ã%‘A,3So[n
GSP
õ3+±õ3

$%
A,Q)*+F/cD

A,Q¤Þß3S‹Œçm‰9
》。2000
y

z
30
{

%
‘,¤×¿3So.¥ABD

,¤¼Þß3S‹Œ
》(2000
P
),
¦y

z


mn
。2001
y
12
z

{
,《
$Æ$:”¬%,¤3S

¦š¾¾eË/‡,¤
¼Å)L2Ö<
GSP
ôŠŠr
。2012
y
11
z

{&Â1ù¯@¸

,¤¼Þß3
S‹Œ
》(2012
P
),
•
2013
y

z

{ámn
 
a€š‹•·>

Ñ
GMP
Ï4d+19[
c

Ëß[n

a…Q

Á5Å)•67ë

Qëe
ËôŠ

WÑÍ[Óäwn)

/—˜¶n)*+¬
Fœ±2µ

[¶ôŠg0±õöI×

L317
AB3S

#ÝôŠ7.

#ܯ°Þß
q
2 
$,Š
GAP
􊸹
Fig2 ThecertificationprocessofChinesemateriamedicaGAP
eËÂÈÑ[\ÂÈâíŽÇûº±’“É›fS7
ÈÉÑ4ù±Å

eËÂÈ·¸nÈ3Sñß

[úpž
%8œ

nžÂȅ†Þßt9ü
),
[\ÂÈÉ·¸4ù
ñßÖn’:±œ

I½Õü¿;²$)[16],
¦Àí
ÈÉTŸ±¯°œl÷Ͻ

·=4ù ¨h̎ùVÀí
TŸ±/‡

àï

$,Š
GAP
ôŠ‚âí¿½9㤱
J—÷

‚6d
GAP
$,Šñ[ú$,ŠŽÅ8w
———
@
¸‹Œ_……±ätD$,Šã¤± Õ

32 GAP
ôŠL°±0ž‚úî
ôŠÉ˾´±«¬.ë8êý[

ôŠ±9ÞÉ
[v<±Ô`¬mѸ¹

[Ø¯±ôŠ°Å

RSv
<ÂȱËâ

v<±Ô`

v<±W¶

ôŠÉ[·=
4ù•$± ¨


GAP
ôŠ±L°É%‘ò¤,¤×
¿3So
(CFDA),
LÌ+ì–
CFDA
Ñ4ù±0ž¥ª>

„
CFDA
×34ù±L?¥[c

321 
ôŠÇŸ4ùn•
 
HQ:/J—±É

ôŠ

Ñ

ôM

¿J`

ôŠÑôM—`ì‚
“Certification”
¬
“Ac
creditation”,
ôŠëBŠú±dÊ

ÿBve˵

ôMëB
íM±dÊ

ôMŽe˜šSø±‰n
[17]。
›æ¶
GAP
â0•[íMË

@A
CFDA
P*%‘ÖníMÉMn
±

}ɛæ
GAP
â0•ôŠ

{:/³Lœf÷Ön

CFDA
{:/¦ôŠf÷oyäôMf÷

ì³LœÖnô
M
)、
×Bf÷

ì³LœÖn׿

¬ÂÈËâf÷

Ëâ
ôŠ±ÂÈ

û‘÷Ï

322 
ôŠ-BC7±š‹
 
¿4ù_fËíÍn$

GAP
ôŠË¾¬vrM·
,《
$Æ$:”¬%ã¤Þ
ߝ

¬

$Æ$:”¬%ôŠôMÒ¨

•ôŠ±I×#
GDw÷±3S˾¬/—±š·>

4ùñßMa@¸
’“šI×
GAP
ôŠg0
。CFDA
Ma@¸ÑôŠ×¿
·5711·
2016
y

z ³
41
ų

}
Vol41,No.7 April,2016
3S17”¦ØÙÂȬ3S˾ç±ì
GAP
ôŠ±BÉ
×3

¦§dD$,Š±Þß8w

¿±B±ôŠôM‹
í

#GDÞß3S°ÅôŠ¬ã¤ôŠ

ôŠ

Ñ$,
Š
GAP
€±Ð)
GAP
ǟã¤ôŠ±ŒC

$,Š
GAP
MaݦÐ)
GAP
ã¤ôŠ±Ss¬œ

q
3)。
q
3 
³LœôŠ±Ë¾´19ñE
[18]
Fig3 Thebasicframeworkofinstitutionaleconomicsofthird
partycertification
4 
$,Š
GAP
±m×
41 

GAP
âí¦‹ŒÂÈo •½ÞÂÈ
Àí

$,Š
GAP
àÌɋŒÂÈ

@¸%‘¬Å)±


aÊÐ)÷Õ÷Ð)‹Œ±ÿ¶

çp÷Gô•É[
½ÞÂÈ

}¿3Sû‘~Ì©H‹ŒÂÈÖn3S

3
b€á½ÞÂȂB±3S˾

¦Ù,¤±:‡Hµ
ò:

6·üId•½Þ?JŽÝ±è

¦4ù:‡±¾
¾Ï#


GAP
ôŠ±SY


GAP
,Šâ0•[Þß
K⎕8w±½Þ,Šh̎ÅùVÅ)¬4ù±:‡

42 
T ÈÉ¿ôŠ$±¾(
¿
GAP
􊸹$

,×17‚¿

œ‘ì4ùÖn
×3

[É@¸BËÂÈdŠ³LœôŠ±VSµ

ۃ@
¸³Lœf÷±ôŠíM‰»L³Lœ±ÈO7.

LÉ@
¸«+Öì³LœôŠçm׿

³Lœ‚|ÉÊn)
C‘–±

avM•¼d

zãÂÈËâ17¬ôMf÷
׿±vÈÉ17

¿$,Š
GAP
¸¹$

ÂÈËâ…R
‚|ÉÊC)ÂÈõ3+·>4ù:‡Ëâ

ôMf÷¬
×Bf÷MaÊ%‘ò¤,¤×¿3Suo
(CFDA)
”¦“
¼

€ü”¦õ3³LœI×
GAP
ôŠ

¬Ön׿

¸´Ss‰]@.¥»x
GAP
􊸹

Ó$
b›1—ÉrB±
GAP
􊸹

盕.¥»x±
GAP
􊸹

q
4)。
ÊqM]
CFDA
±Fí¥ 

~ÌÉnÈ
ôMf÷

}ÓôMì-Ê1FT•ôM³LœôŠf÷

³Lœf÷
(ThirdpartyCertifiers,
Á¼
TPC)
N˕¿vM;
<4ùôM
,CFDA
Ma@¸4ùÖO
TPC
vMç±ì
TPC
f÷±{w×3

q
4 
´Ss‰]@±
GAP
􊸹
Fig4 UndertheguidanceofeconomicstheoryofGAPcertifica
tionprocess
43 
ØÙôŠŠú°Å¬4ùìzfË
[ôŠ¸¹L2RS

ô¦

Ñ

Šú
”2
§¨

ô
¦Éì$,Š±Â㸹ùV
GAP
Âȱô¦

[ú:/
@¸‚™±œóç±

Šú{:/@¸³Lœ

Šú$

±
vM¼d

•ã¤#GŠú

[Ø¯±ôŠ°ÅRSô¬
Š±

¸¹

±§¨

ô

±¸¹€ìØÙ

}

Š

±¸¹
¾éˆ

•D#ÝÅ)!n
GAP
±2µL2€á
GAP
1FôŠY±Šú°Å

ÍOPÍÅƬ‘ëBËè
SY[¶
GAP
Šú¸¹±€»

€áMÍ>±ÞßPQ°ÅQÁU±œóÉ@¸q
±œól4ùW¶v<

Àí
GAP
,ŠéˆBɱã¤
Âõ_ó

]c
GAP
,ŠÑ[ú,Š¿4ù±xMφ
rJ—

ã¤Âi±éˆI<
GAP
,Š¿4ù÷±;²
½ßRVS&

¦´±¾¾—à

•D[¶j‘¬4ù
ì
GAP
,Š±ôM¹¾

L2»xÞßv<ì
GAP
,Š@
¸4ùTUW¶

5 
$,Š
GAP
ôŠ:/åd±’“
51 
ôŠ±š1i
GAP
ôŠ¬vrM·

%R>Ö6D%‘ò¤,¤×
¿3Suo±
GAP
ôŠ

¬vdþÑ
GAP
˾±¸œ

§É
GAP
¥Ë¾±VÂ

HQ

%R>ɦÁÈ;‰±¾¾Ö6
GAP
ôŠ

¬vÅâ
GAP
ì4ù±d0
,GAP
Maݦ[ú
Q¤±ôŠG¹.¥Ê«+ñßÝÑËâ

«+_±œóÍ
0
GAP
ùV%‘TŸ±…Èœ5
。《
$Æ$:”¬%ôŠô
MÒ¨

•«+ñßI×ôŠg0#GDš?W

àïò,
uo
GAP
ôŠ±Ö6É«+_
GAP
ôŠV±Iì

52 
e_(Y3S
¿
GAP
«+_ìôŠf÷±m׸¹$

//—Ö=
(˜U óm×±‹š

f÷íMÑÍÖn

¿ôŠñß3
bÍáO

‚|i+¿ê=‘f÷ôŠ

ê=‘ôŠ±
½ëÉ$,X…úî

3Sœ&

¦O¥éˆ;²fË

­®
DM{YÊäZ[±’“

ÈÉ츍ŸÂÈËâ

׿

ôM±û‘÷ì³LœÖn3S

êÓÉì
GAP
Å)¬³
LœôŠf÷±(Y3S

20b\ôŠ

b\6W蒓
]Æ,Š4ù^™

·6711·
P 


$,Š‹Œ_Ž
(GAP)
‘’“Q”
53 
ØÙÙ÷lm
GAP
o •½ÞÂÈ

Ã/¦ÙÑÓâîB±½ÞÂ
ÈÖn_Ù

ÚF,ŠôŠ¬$,ŠQ¤‹èè^ôŠýþ
±Å/úî

¦¯Y±8è÷Ï#

Q¤‹èè^ÂȂ
èé
GAP
,ŠÂȬÚF,ŠÂÈ
,GAP
,ŠÂȂèé
ÚF,ŠÂÈ

$,Š
GAP
ÉdŠ$,Þß±[ ¨

‚adŠ$,±ˆÉ•S

‚Ñ$ASsd+[c

¿
GAP
1F±;G

Ž()¬pªÅgœ‘

‚å.Ñ$A
,Wƍƒ±œV

å.Þß±í#@`—ãß


„q=

[1] 
$Æ$:”¬%%‘Æxo

$%Æxy<
[DB/OL].
(20150830).htp://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/ndsj/.
[2] 
!3Õ

ì$%$,Š
GAP
1F±²±^”—à
[J].
Ð
k
,2012,2(3):65.
[3] 
DÖH

$,Š‹Œ_ŽÑ
GAP
ôŠÖ×
[J].
.a$
,«¬
,2012(1):43.
[4] 
yEÛ

[Ö$,Š‹Œ_Ž

Åe
GAP
ôŠY±ieÊ
4ùIÜ
[J].
Hb,
,2011,23(1):155.
[5] 
!lª

Qa¥

,žŽ˜ºÂP›Ñ$,Š
GAP[J].
’“
&()
———
$A,±P_
,2005,7(2):67.
[6] 
ÀÝÞ

c3 

de•

$,Š
GAP
çm±æ-ÅÆs
[J].
$%$,-.
,2002,27(1):1.
[7] 
Dàm

fg‚

h‹i

è

žvâ()[¶$,Š
GAP
±
çm
[J].
$,
,2004,53(10):108.
[8] 
Qáx

!_

Gj5

è

$,Š‹Œ_Âã
(GAP)10
y

–æ

’“Ñ€¯
[J].
$%$,-.
,2014,39(7):1143.
[9] 
cEú

Ikl

y$m

è


GAP
Ì4±M²Þß~

[J].
$,
,2002,33(1):75.
[10] 


ãSä
GAP
ÂÈ~°Å±€«¬
[D].
Óo

Ó
o$A,…
,2002.
[11] 
!Ïá

D3<

p_5

è


GAP
ÂÈq0‹¹


ò
)[J].
±P$,«¬Ñçâ
,2003,17(1):8.
[12] 
r.ú

lç5

&¥s

è

ÜÝ
GAP
‹Œ_Ì4()
[J].
tKÐ)&
,2004(6):98.
[13] 
uv


GAP
ôŠ«¬Ñçâ
[J].
$Ý«¬
,2012,25
(2):60.
[14] 
,wn

,KK

B€x

è

Õ÷Ð)‹Œ
(GAP)
ÊÓ¿$
%0˜8wÂã$±‚ž±²Ñ×y
[J].
$%Ð)&(]
k
,2009,11(5):42.
[15] 
,wn

,KK

B€x

è

Õ÷Ð)‹Œ
(GAP)
ÊÓ¿$
%0˜8wÂã$±‚ž±²Ñ×y
[J].
$%Ð)&(]
k
,2009,11(5):42.
[16] 
P3

Iz

Qáx

è

¦vâ¥ì¼±¾¾—à

$%,
˜

ÂÈ3S$,±oCµ
[J].
$%$,-.
,2013,38
(23):4168.
[17] MirandaPMMeuwissen,AnnetGJVelthuis,HenkHogeveen,et
al.Technicalandeconomicconsiderationsabouttraceabilityand
certificationinlivestockproductionchains[M]//Newapproa
chestofoodsafetyeconomics.Wageningen:KluwerAcademic
Publishers,2003:41.
[18] GabrieleJahn,MathiasSchramm,AchimSpiler.Thereliability
ofcertification:qualitylabelsasaconsumerpolicytool[J].J
ConsumPolicy,2005,28:53.

€-0
 
Ÿ ¡

·7711·