免费文献传递   相关文献

Process and key points of clinical literature evaluation of post-marketing traditional Chinese medicine

中成药上市后临床文献评价的流程与要点



全 文 :#‡ˆyo
#
rÚÇ_S¾?@7«9:[Ži&-
¼›
#
cde
!
!
9<9IJ¯K 9I°±²³I¯MNO
#
´µ
PMM[MM
$
ž;
%!
rÚÇ_S¾?@7«9:Îm¡OTÂ#
#
6‹ÇÌ[j‰ƒ„7«
!
AÇÌ[èé›
#
EO›
#
ˋ›‡R
És7«Æ)[šÄ9©
!
ÎAÆÇÌ9:[|Ø6

7«9:]rÇ_S¾?@Ö9:r֝s©Ñ‰Š[QI

m
¡7«9:
!
*OTNO_SÇÌ[7«n
#
ýOrǟ ü5—[ò†
#
R|l./?@š\¥
#
(ǟh.Æ
‡

t7,£´rÇ_S¾?@7«9:[‚&l§ii-

C–EO›7«9:\iæOTH®ÇŸ[EO›n
&
è
é›9:\?irÇ]¾(Ƥ
#
µÁpFãŒY·…T[¯{é}
&
ˋ]7«9:\?@ƒ„…”Ñ0,[*+›
#
­
oi®Ó›

$
Ÿ ¡
%!
_S¾9:
&
rÚÇ
&
7«ƒ„
&
AÆU]
$
8$f
%!WMPPMNM^MML
$
‘’Ep
%!
­æ
)
i¬ŠÇBÜ
*
ö÷i¬«u
$WMM_e+M_LMW;
MOM%
$
“Ž>”
%!
!
­®¯
!
ƒ„°
!
?@ãûA
!
ƒ„…†êrU?@9
:…”ƒ„
!@(&.$MPM% X^MP^^PP;OOMW!-;I$&. #`)$)bWMPM\A$#//F
G/IFG)
$
>”š›
%!
£ó
!
’ƒ„°
!
ƒ„…†êrU?@9:…”ƒ„
!
@(&.$MPM%X^MP^^PP;OOLP!-;I$&.#4$)$))(\0)$FG/I
!!
rÇ_S¾Ö9:[7«ƒ„Îm¡OTÂ#
#
6‹r
ÚÇ[j‰ƒ„7«
!
AÇÌ[èé›
#
EO›
#
ˋ›‡R
És7«Æ)[šÄ9©
!
ÎAÆÇÌ9:
$(D5()G(;
b$0(5 5%4*(D$&4$2/)!-7R-%
[|Ø6

¤7‚&,£rÚ
Ç_S¾?@7«9:[‚&l§ii-

!
rÇ_S¾?@7«9:[‚&l§
!b!
/Ô7«9:[v[
!
ê)¥Øü[&Jǟã
ä­W[×./7«ƒ„[v[

|Ÿ;h
!
m¡OTô
¥rÚÇ[?@\›Ñƒ„R±[7«
!
謝OT
#
»/
9:rÚÇ[èé›ÑEO›
!
R|l´ŒrÚÇ[¯-
!
ê_S¾?@Ö9:…úá.µo¦)
!
±f§Rǟ[*
C˜±
!
Â&¬Sƒ

wþfž
!
`*<ǟ[§|
…TRÉ7«ƒ„Ñ_S¾Ö9:
!
ûǟ6A§|š\¥
[èé›Jǟ\›§|i [ÇÌˋ]9:‡

!b#
ÜÔïO.~
!
ê)7«9:[v[/ÔïO[n
¬
$
û()N
%#
ïO…}
#
ïO‹ÑïO}
#
#Ô¦q‡

vh
!
›[ïO…}Î.P;ïO
!
›™(
)N[õNïO
!
-…L
#
ö

ìû•CÄѕ7«
!
J
FæèÑ.f()NH%[7«
!
è7`\›žNïO
!
J
žNi.P;0Ä[…}
!
OTH®j‰[7«

([ïOstÎZ7͛¿}‹ilϋ
!
>›¼¶
9P/
!
û¼¶
)
i
*$)=>R*%#
¼¶
)
J
*$)T3*%#
¼¶
)
-
*
$)>T@*%
‡=Ä¥ÙÄ

è7×&A7«RɪÑ#Ô
!
û¼÷#
#
7«úž ¨
#
ƒ„±G
#
ƒ„¨â‡


#
j
CѽÁïOstÎ&»ÀŽïO0•[i&l§

!b$
OTCÄÆ)
!
êOTb®™Â
!
×&’“ÏËÜÔ[
ïO.~
!
]¿ n¬rCÄÆ)
!
wx›()N
#
«W
()N
#
Vœ¸¹
#
äň&
#
]Ñ,7®
#
÷{7«‡

ûr
­rUǕ§7«()N
$#2U.ZZEEEFG)2GIF$GFG)%#

ãÌU]7«()N
$7<50G%#
r­•§O7()N
#
þ…
()™¬Fã
#
r7ãÌU]•§()N
$<%#
¹†™ª
$#2U.ZZEEEFG]DUFG/I%#
rUÇ1§()N
#
­æö]÷Ñ
dÆ7«rß
$#2U.ZZEEEF)02&F*/DFG)Z)5(KF#2I&%#
r­­
ædÆø·;–Ðv%
$#2U.ZZEEEF)&GF*/DFG)Z%#
r­«¬
()N
#
­æö÷ڕ¸
$#2U.ZZEEEF)$02F/%*FG)Z%
G
84b<(5!-<7=1-!/G#%$)(
dÆø
$/G#%$)(Bb%$%A!B%
‡

!b%
7«r´
!
7«H®
.
ïO¾pØ\RÉ7«H®
!
w
x.fÂ7«O7ªý
#
Y7«jp
$
\?@7«KÖ[
ž›
%
7«r´Ñž¥
.
ê)ƒ„v[A7«Rɹl[ž
¥
!
NKij
#

#
-‚D7«
!
>*RÉ6¨
#
¨e
#
W


AïÐ6‹[7«
!
¯©ÎRÉFã9:7
!
\/Ô
7«ïÐÀ+
#
¨äÀ+
!
>σ„±°RÉ«„[7«r
´

Z7
!
\ü%>h.ïÐѨä7«[(·Ñ¥Ï

]
7«r´r
!
*Í›7«¥Žq
!
û
3(6(%()G(<$)$*(%!
-)5>/2(!8%/2(
‡
!
聝7«¥

!b&
7«Y·9:
!
’“7«Y·9:À+ÑÆ)6ºÀ
+AïÐ7«RÉY·9:

7«Y·9:‚&9©7«
1ù[ƒ„á.ΝĥG0,[*+›Ñö]›

|
/N^NW/
{
OX
ï{
WM
•
WMPP
÷
PM
²
!!!!!! ! ! ! ! ! !!!! ! ! ! !
S/&fOX! :004(!WM
TG2/b(%! WMPP
ŸÏ
W
M9©±°RÉ«„[7«9:

A\;A“ç¨
$%$)5/I`(5 G/)2%/&(5 2%$&!3@%

’“
,
?@ç¨1ù[ã|À+
-
P(
$/)0/&5$2(5 12$)5$%50
/63(U/%2)*@%$&0!T>1T3@%
G
,
™Ç\;A“?@ç¨
[1ù
.T>1T3@
Ù.\œ
- $
ªyP
,
­1™Ç
T>;
1T3@
Ù.
-%
W(
´Œªá.…ú
#
§¸¡
#
6‹…”Ñ0
•Œ0
!
>Eê7«Y·9:À+
!
•ª0•[)§›

Æ)6ºÀ+
.
YZ[ƒ„á.¨â
!
ª0•[,ÆC
è²CE
!
XYfž
!
á„A“[?@ƒ„,ÆCÁ
º»›ƒ„
&
Fã9:[0•,ÆCÁH[?@ç
¨
&
\;A“?@ç¨Á-\;A“ç¨
&
º»›ƒ„r
!
ÔJƒ„
#
iP
;
A“ƒ„
#
ӏT–C
#
FJiP1a
#
ú
1a[,ÆC¦5WX

­~`è]FµK´6ArU
Ç[?@Æ)6º
!
*‘
O(

!b
™Âµ#
!
êLA7«[6‹ÑÎï
!
\AïÐ7
«[‚&™ÂRɵ#

™Âµ#¼Å[~\ê)v[
#
Ð6‹[uvá.
!
\y.‡&
#
gt&Î

µ#¼á.¡
r
!
è7×&RÉç›
!
>Rɽ¾
#
(

µ#[‚&~wx7«WfG;¬
#
ƒ„…”
#
ƒ„
Aô[É´
#
I‰°¸
#
‚&0•‡

À|´µcÎ[0-

!
æè0-!ÀJ0-!ÀY*É7
!
\cÎ[¾ô
!Àô¾
!
>RÉÀ?

™Âµ#\Ï
W
Mƒ„±°RÉ«„[µ#
!
û•äã
YZ@#7
!
m¡,†#&|q

!b(
™Â6‹
!
ê)YZ[™Â#YZ[6‹…”
!
w
xcÎ[ã.…”

û•ƒ„æè?@ã.]EY›
!
*A
()RÉÔ·Ä>6‹
!
Ó
<(2$

&
œ<\ÎRÉԛ


HïÐ[ƒ„*nYÁ
#
YgÞß9:[&JY
gŒ¼RèD
!
*–ž7«ïOstiŠïOŠ[Æ
)
!
Jê)NE×&µKª|l[ƒ„.~

!b)
|Ú7«ƒ„1ù
!
A7«6‹1ù[0,\h.
Îsâ º©[Æ)&K[0,
!
Z7£\h.0•[
®Ó›

#
EO›7«9:&-
#b!
OTCÄÆ)
!
EO›7«9:\ÎïOi›Çè‰
[²è­~®7«™Â
!
wxÇŸEO›êƒ„v[[™
Â
#
ǟèé›êƒ„v[[™Â
#
A_S¾Y“”\1ù
FãH®[iP™Â
$
û­W_S¾ÇŸY“”\W%(
)
#
­æǟY“”\W%rß[W%()
%
[È¡›6‹

#
»]ƒ„
$
Ï#&r•ƒ„0•
%
Jϝڃ„ìß
¼[?@ƒ„()
$
÷{7«
%
GY“”\ú1a‡

#b#
7«r´
!
EO›7«9:äïÐ\;A“種
!
£\ïÐ-\;A“ç¨[ƒ„
!
‘&7òÝïÐỄ„
[0•

-\;A“ç¨GªFã9:wx?@-\;A
“ç¨
#
ÔJƒ„
#
iP
;
A“ƒ„
#
R´ƒ„
#
ãì]ƒ„
#
iPFJ
#
iP1ùGªÑ.ã[ŽÉi]ƒ„¨â
$
ûi
PÊùƒ„
#
h}iP
;
A“ƒ„‡
%
#b$
7«Y·9:
!
\;A“ç¨[Y·9:Zèé›
&
Y
Z¨â-\;A“稃„[Y·
$
wZl¿1ù()
%!
×0
ÄwþÉ´RÉ9:

9:~‚&‘ºƒ„á.
#
§¸
#
ã.
6‹Ñ0•1ù‡Ã…T
!
i-ÎBd}Ü

7«Y·9:0
•iǟEO›7«9:0,>,‘é·F
!
*gr­AÆ
U]rßÓZ[Y“×qJEO›9:[Æ)6‹À+

#b%
™Âµ#
!
EO›7«9:[™Âµ#¼äwx7«
9:[|Ÿ~®
!
£\wxY“”\ãÉ´¾£
#
݂
É´
#
Ä>›ÇÉ´
#
Y“”\KÎ
#
ՉF‡

#b&
™Â6‹
!
EO›7«9:‚&RÉԛ6‹
!

¾£›ã.6‹…”AEO›™ÂRÉÎï
!
*›J¼|
}1ù0•

AúiP\Î9:™ÂΝrO
!
Չ
FΝڄ

\Î0ÄՕÈœR¬6‹>³K0,

#b
|Ú7«9:1ù
!
\Î0ÄEO›×qã[¢P
Gª2išÄ9:ǟEO×q[i&›ÑŸ 
!
AEO›9:0•RɌ0

]EO›7«9:[À¾
!
ÎsÇŸ[èé›
!
³Kǟ¬ëc|[šÄ9©0,
^(

$
èé›7«9:&-
$b!
OTCÄÆ)
!
èé›7«9:i-ïOFã9:1
ùi\;A“ç¨
!
û•æ臺YÁ[Æ)
!
œ×&ïO
Æ)8 jAYÁ[7«

”÷;
!
­1_ArUǃ„ð
ñò™
!
`èj‰[,7GFã9:¼
!
\?@ïO
#
H
®®77«

­~\;A“ç¨ÑFã9:`]òx[–
—
!
ìϝ¿»È˜7«ƒ„Y·[Ÿ 
!
{™Fã9:`
w&K/ØÑÌÔ[0,

\ê)YZ¨â7«
!
9©ª
ƒ„Y·Ñ,ÆC
!
•A_SrÇ[èé›EKö]
#
º
#
Ä¥[9:

$b#
7«Y·9:
!
Fã9:J
<(2$
6‹*“
TKI$) m
?4A$2
·¼J
d,T3T<
Ù.1ùÓ29:ª1ùY·

;A“ç¨9:À+‚&“
/G#%$)(.$)5b//V
ÓZÀ
+

\A“7«9©[À+
!
ù\g7«
!
ðuA7«[
ƒ„…”RÉ9©
!
>µKšÄ[7«Y·96

‘&7*
A
W
M9:F[9:0•RÉ|q›ï¨

$b$
èé›9:r[rUǯ{
!
rǙ±žþýOb
é
!
ªèé›!À[´µ`\±žþK
!
Yç&wxi&
[?@×q
$

#
íîJFŒ‡
%#
ÞgëìGiƤ
j‰[¥ëGþЇº!À
!
£&wx¿çFAabé
•[5þÞ@ÑãŒY·‡‚º!À

괏aºQ
ArÚÇ[èé›RÉ9:
!
`*´µÍ›?@Œú]

#
i¥!ÀGã¥ã\!À

ÓArÇèé›[9:
\F¡?@¥ë!ÀÑ?@ï¨!À=¬!ÀþF
!
¼¨
¼*þRrU¦Æ,a[¯{
!
´gš\RôU]A$
ibé9:[&
L(

\›­1bé•ÔÀ+
!
µÁ­1
(*

$iÑƤ
#
ãŒY·[9:>i
!
YgÆ¤b
é9:ô¾A$ibé[9:
!
`Yg…ærÇ]¾(Æ
/_^NW/
{
OX
ï{
WM
•
WMPP
÷
PM
²
!!!!!! ! ! ! ! ! !!!! ! ! ! !
S/&fOX! :004(!WM
TG2/b(%! WMPP
¤#
µÁpFãŒY·…T[¯{é}

%
ˋ]7«9:&-
%b!
ƒ„…”
!
7«\͛/Ô[ÇÌˋ][9/ƒ„
…”
$
Ú¤é›6‹
#
À6Ú¤”
#
Ú¤é•6‹
#
Ú¤éë

#
Ú¤¬›P6‹
%!
fé‘çšÄƒ„v[

Pû&
XYé•jZ[
W
 Ç
!
×ÊÀ6Ú¤”ÎĚ[

ƒ„á.\tóû.´

¶±º[[›hh›ƒ
„
!
ìÈ¡›6‹[™ÂÀÆ
!
Y\…æ

H|uƒ„þ
Î\;?@ç¨[|Ø6
!
ªË‹]0•*g”É[΃„
…ú
!
ߑÎ
)
m[ab
*!
fº»›ƒ„[[g|Q”
Ém[ab
!
ì΅eã.][hžN

&9©¼¨[ƒ
„0•i&EK[¼ÔJ]ö[j‰
!
‘çórQ´Œ
]ö~m[abÎüÊ
#
YZƒ„á.[é}GYß

Ÿ Ã—[´µ{i&

\ý£JÝeµG²èj‰
ab…”
!
›;XY[ab…”G›ÇÛ·\tÎmÉ´
ª/§›[

ΝèÆ)gÆ.²´[ab…”Ñ›Ç
Û·/§èé
2
jµgšRÉXY[ab´µÑžÇ´µ
Νi]ö
#
pFG
#
¼Ôè‰
2
¼cDì\tþór

%b#
€›Gé•
!
ƒ„±°\/(7 o´ab…”OØ
i&[j‰€›G¾•
!
/(>%P[€›*gÎûï[
#
š
ï[G,|[€›
!
0•J¾•*Îƒ„r•[
!
Jƒ„0
0[
!
féwx9:KR
$
ûabE›
%
GY9:KR[
$
û
’E›
%#
?@_
#
ˋ_G±a@è_[0•
!
Îé¼c
0•i´µ[ab…”è·F

£&þó€›G0•Îi
]öѼÔj‰
&

!
ƒ„F“›[();¬Î*+

%b$
0,[*+›
#
­oi®Ó›
!
\Al⃄àá
G*g[2#›=á6[†,

†,\wx\›tڕj
‰[O؍D
!
ûƒ„›[ã.…”
#
ƒ„0,Νĥ
‡

ƒ„±°\%窃„0•[­o
!
Óm¡9Ô͛F
0•[D\;%ç|uˋ]6‹[*+[¡

0,
[\››`-i&
!
\<7«[0,=†,
!
Lýƒ„
0,Ó6»§1NEr

±ƒ„0•rÂ&[0,‘çμ
*Æ.
$
~]»/›
%
`*Îï
$
®]»/›
%
X(
!

!
0,
\týã._u¡[0•i?@èé[0•(©—;

$
œ‡ˆ
%
P(!C())(2# J1G#4&`!R/4*&$0?=&2I$)! R$D5 ‡
fT>;
1T3@WMPM
Ù.
.
1ù ÉA“\;?@ç¨!ý[Š
9(f
r)U0Ä]1
!WMPM!N$[%.XM^f
W(!9/(&9?$*) (%! .($2#(%7//)! 8$4&$3/G#/)! (2$&fJ/%2#(
T>1T3@*%/4Uf3(U/%2)*%$)5/I`(5!G/)2%/&(5 2%$&0/6#(%b$&
)2(%D()2/)0. $) (&$b/%$2(5 T>1T3@02$2(I()29(f=)) :)2(%)
<(5!WMMX! P^^.OXf
O(!
£D 
f
!ãU]Æ)þ[1ÚGÆ)6º[DÅ
9(f
r
­r)U0Ä£¤
!WMM[!W[$PW%.PMXPf
^(!
­æhŸÇŸWi¥2ǟ9:rß
f
ǟ7«9:!û
Ȝ
$
Ð@#
WMM_fP%
L(!
ò ¨
!
Ø.
f
ÇÌˋ]9:rrÚÇè雍D[F†
9(f
r­Ç¤
!WMMX!P[$PP%.NWNf
X(!
D;˜
!
òú
!
£ÿŠ
f
ÇÌˋ]7«™Â[9:i\›
9(f
Ç]§.£¤
!WMMP!P_$P%.^Lf
PGBLAKK/CHVAF OB0CDKBNL10C0L/110DAG/DIGAAS/1I/D0BCBN
OBKD-./GVAD0CW DG/H0D0BC/12E0CAKA.AH0L0CA
B:,.4$)! +:-c$)I)*
!
$#$!%!&!()*+$%,-$+.,/ %# 01%#%,+123%,%#! 0/%#+ 4,+356()0/%#$23%,+17,%#,$! *%8%#9 PMM[MM! 0/%#+%
6MKDG/LD( @#(G&)G$&&2(%$24%((D$&4$2/) /62#(U/02;I$%V(2)*2%$52/)$&#)(0(I(5G)(0$G/IU%(#()0D((D$&4$2/)
bA2#(G/IU%(#()0D(*$)! $)$&A00/62#(5%4*! &2(%$24%(/65%4*(6G$GA! 0$6(2A! (G/)/IA! b$0(5 /) 2#(&2(%$24%((D5()G($)5 0
U$%2/62#((D$&4$2/) /6(D5()G(;b$0(5 I(5G)(f@#(&2(%$24%((D$&4$2/) ) 2#(U/02;I$%V(2)*#)(0(I(5G)(G&)G$&(D$&4$2/)
0) 2#(6/4)5$2/) $)5 2#(V(AU/02/)f@#%/4*# 2#(&2(%$24%((D$&4$2/)! 2G$) 64&A*%$0U 2#()6/%I$2/)! *%$0U &02(5 5%4*D$%(2A
/62%$52/)$&#)(0(I(5G)(00(G/)5 5(D(&/UI()2/%()2$2/)! I$V(G&($%64%2#(%G&)G$&)5G$2/)0! U(%6(G22#(I(5G)(0! (2Gf
@#0U$U(%50G400(02#(I$) 02(U0$)5 (IU#$00/62#(G&)G$&&2(%$24%((D$&4$2/)f-IU#$0`)*0(G4%2A&2(%$24%((D$&4$2/) 0#/4&5
$2$G# IU/%2$)G(2/2#(0(G4%2A/6$G/IU%(#()0D(G/&(G2/) 5%4*)6/%I$2/)F1$6(2A$00(00I()20#/4&5 )/2G(2%$52/)$&#)(0(
I(5G)(D$&52A(D$&4$2/) ) IU%/D)*0A)5%/I(!IU%/D()*2#(&D)*]4$&2A/6U$2()20E2# 0U(G$&$5D$)2$*(F@#((G/)/IG0&2;
(%$24%((D$&4$2/) 0#/4&5 U$A$2()2/) 2/%(&$b&2A! 0()02D2A$)5 U%$G2G$b&2A/62#(G/)G&40/)
[AF XBGHK(! (D$&4$2/) /62#(U/02;I$%V(2)*5%4*& 2%$52/)$&#)(0(I(5G)(& &2(%$24%(%(0($%G#& (D5()G(;b$0(5 I(5;
G)(
HB0.!+c%#)RLYL..#+!!#+#%
$
•–$Q
!
—˜™
%
/MLNW/
{
OX
ï{
WM
•
WMPP
÷
PM
²
!!!!!! ! ! ! ! ! !!!! ! ! ! !
S/&fOX! :004(!WM
TG2/b(%! WMPP